Raynal expressed his surprise at the timing enforced by World Rugby, citing a prior consensus that changes would align with the international window. "We are extremely surprised by the timetable imposed by World Rugby," Raynal disclosed in an interview with Rugbyrama. "We had agreed, with all the nations and World Rugby, that any new rule would only come into effect during the July international window. We will therefore naturally ask World Rugby for an explanation regarding this change of timetable."
World Rugby's recent decision includes an immediate ban on knee-drop tackles and a prohibition of hip-drop tackles starting from November 1. While Raynal appreciates the focus on player safety, he questioned the execution timing for the hip-drop tackle ban, highlighting a gap where no clear guidelines exist. "The hip-drop tackle is a dangerous form of tackle," he noted. "This is a very positive step, which we welcome. That being said, if this type of tackle presents a significant enough danger to justify regulatory intervention, why not implement this measure immediately? What should we do about this type of tackle between now and 1 November?"
"We are extremely surprised by the timetable imposed by World Rugby,"
The former Test referee also pointed out that the sanctions for hip-drop tackles remain unclear, which complicates the job for officials. He added that French referees are still waiting for detailed guidance on expected penalties for such infractions.
On the matter of knee-drop tackles, Raynal argued that this form of tackling was already outlawed, as it involves tackling an opponent from the ground. "It’s positive that this prohibition is now explicitly formalised," he stated. "However, it has always been forbidden to tackle an opponent when you are yourself on the ground. In France, we have been refereeing and penalising this type of tackle with a knee on the ground for over two and a half years. For us, this formalisation therefore changes absolutely nothing."
This controversy sheds light on the challenges and frustrations faced by national rugby authorities when international governing bodies abruptly change regulations. The shift by World Rugby not only impacts players but also referees who must adapt swiftly to ensure the game's fairness and safety are maintained.
